Depreciation Factors – What Holds Value, What Tanks It

Same car, same year—₹2 lakh difference in resale. One is white Maruti with authorized service. The other is orange Volkswagen with local garage history.

Depreciation isn’t random. Specific factors predictably affect resale value: brand perception, color psychology, fuel type trends, transmission preferences, ownership count, and regional variations. Understanding these dynamics helps you buy cars that hold value and avoid money pits.

What you’ll learn:

• Brand hierarchy and retention rates (Maruti 60% vs VW 35%)
• Color impact on resale (white premium, bright color penalty)
• Fuel type dynamics (diesel declining, petrol rising)
• Transmission preferences (manual vs automatic types)
• Ownership count effects (single owner premium)
• Regional variations (metro vs tier-2 preferences)
• Decision framework for value retention

---

Brand Hierarchy and Retention Rates

The Champions (60-65% Retention After 5 Years)

Maruti Suzuki:

• Unmatched 3,000+ service center network
• Abundant spare parts availability
• Buyer trust = easiest resale
• Example: 2020 Swift ₹6L → 2025 resale ₹3.6-4L

Toyota:

• Legendary reliability reputation
• Lower maintenance costs
• Example: 2020 Glanza ₹7L → 2025 resale ₹4.2-4.5L

Hyundai:

• Strong brand image in India
• Modern features attract buyers
• Example: 2020 i20 ₹8L → 2025 resale ₹4.8-5.2L

In simple terms: These brands are like iPhone in phones—everyone wants them used, they hold value because buyers trust the brand.

The Fighters (50-55% Retention)

Tata Motors:

• Improving perception
• Safety ratings help resale
• Example: 2020 Nexon ₹9L → 2025 resale ₹4.5-5L

Mahindra:

• SUV expertise recognized
• Rural network strength
• Example: 2020 XUV300 ₹10L → 2025 resale ₹5-5.5L

Honda:

• Engineering reputation
• Limited to specific models (City, Amaze)
• Example: 2020 City ₹11L → 2025 resale ₹5.5-6L

Kia:

• New but gaining ground rapidly
• Strong warranty helped initial sales
• Example: 2020 Seltos ₹14L → 2025 resale ₹7-7.7L

The Strugglers (35-45% Retention)

Volkswagen & Skoda:

• Service cost fears (expensive parts)
• Limited service network
• Example: 2020 Polo ₹7L → 2025 resale ₹2.5-3.2L (harsh depreciation)

Renault & Nissan:

• Uncertain future in India
• Declining dealership network
• Example: 2020 Triber ₹6L → 2025 resale ₹2.1-2.7L

Why such low retention:

• Buyers fear service unavailability in 2-3 years
• Parts scarcity drives costs up
• Resale market limited (fewer buyers)

Luxury Brands (30-40% Retention)

Mercedes, BMW, Audi:

• Massive depreciation (60-70% loss in 5 years)
• Maintenance cost fears
• Example: 2020 Mercedes C-Class ₹45L → 2025 resale ₹13.5-18L

Jaguar Land Rover:

• Reliability concerns compound depreciation
• Service costs astronomical
• Example: 2020 Jaguar XE ₹40L → 2025 resale ₹12-16L

In simple terms: Luxury cars lose value like a stone dropping in water. First owner pays premium, second owner gets a “bargain” that costs ₹2L/year to maintain.

---

Color Psychology and Resale Impact

Winners (Neutral Colors)

White (40% buyer preference):

• Hides dust better (Indian roads)
• Looks newer longer
• Premium: 0-2% over bright colors

Silver (25% preference):

• Hides minor scratches
• Classic resale appeal
• Premium: 0-1%

Grey (15% preference):

• Modern, sophisticated
• Growing popularity
• Neutral: Standard pricing

Acceptable (Standard Colors)

Black (10% preference):

• Premium look when clean
• Shows scratches, dust easily
• Neutral to slight discount: 0-2%

Blue (5% preference):

• Depends on shade (navy better than bright)
• Slight discount: 2-3%

Red (3% preference):

• Sporty but polarizing
• Discount: 3-5%

Avoid (Bright/Unusual Colors)

Orange, Yellow, Green, Purple (<2% each):

• Highly polarizing
• Severely limited buyer pool
• Discount: 5-10% value hit

Example:

• 2020 Creta white: ₹13L asking price
• 2020 Creta orange: ₹11.7-12.4L (₹60K-1.3L less)

In simple terms: Neutral colors are like classic songs—everyone likes them. Bright colors are niche tastes—10 buyers look, 9 walk away because of color alone.

---

Fuel Type Dynamics

Petrol (Rising Preference)

Advantages:

• Lower purchase price (₹1-2L less than diesel)
• Cheaper maintenance
• No DPF/AdBlue issues
• Better resale in small cars

Best for:

• Annual driving <15,000 km
• City use primarily

Resale impact: Neutral to positive (growing preference)

Diesel (Declining for Small Cars, Stable for SUVs)

Advantages:

• Better fuel economy (20-25 km/l vs 15-18 km/l petrol)
• Torque for highway/hills
• Still commands premium in SUVs

Disadvantages:

• Higher purchase price
• DPF issues if city-only use (₹50K-70K replacement)
• Age restrictions (10 years in Delhi-NCR)

Resale impact:

• Small cars (Swift, i20): Diesel losing value
• SUVs (Creta, Seltos): Diesel still valued

CNG (Niche Market)

Factory-fitted:

• Retains 80% of value impact
• Better resale than aftermarket

Aftermarket conversion:

• Value loss: 20-30% (safety concerns, insurance complications)

Best for: High daily mileage (taxi/commercial)

Electric (Unknown Territory)

Battery degradation reality:

• 2-3% capacity loss annually
• 70% capacity at 8 years (replacement trigger)
• Replacement cost: 50-60% of car value

Resale challenge:

• No established market yet
• Buyers fear battery replacement costs

---

Transmission Preferences and Resale

Manual (60% of Used Market)

Why it holds value:

• Most reliable (fewer complex parts)
• Cheapest to maintain/repair
• Widest buyer pool

Resale: Strong demand, standard pricing

Torque Converter Automatic (Premium Segment)

Why it commands premium:

• Most reliable automatic type
• Smooth operation
• Lower repair costs vs CVT/DCT

Resale: +5-10% premium in used market

In simple terms: Torque converter is like a traditional automatic watch—time-tested, reliable, valued by enthusiasts.

CVT (Continuously Variable Transmission)

Why buyers hesitate:

• Overheating concerns in traffic (City CVT issues well-known)
• Expensive repair (₹80K-1.2L replacement)
• Limited service options

Resale impact: 5-10% discount vs manual (buyer caution)

DCT (Dual Clutch Transmission)

Why resale suffers:

• Reliability concerns (Verna DCT juddering, Ecosport DCT issues)
• Expensive clutch replacement (₹45K-60K)
• Jerky behavior in traffic

Resale impact: 10-15% discount vs manual (known problems)

AMT (Automated Manual Transmission)

Why it’s acceptable:

• Simple technology (manual + automated clutch)
• Cheap to repair
• Jerky but reliable

Resale: Neutral (budget segment expects it)

---

Ownership Count Effects

Single Owner (Premium)

Why valued:

• Complete service history likely
• Original owner care
• No documentation complications

Premium: 10-15% over two-owner equivalent

Two Owners (Standard)

Market standard:

• Most used cars fall here
• No value penalty if documented

Pricing: Market rate

Three+ Owners (Discount)

Why discounted:

• Fragmented service history
• Higher risk of issues
• Documentation gaps

Discount: 10-20% below market

Corporate/Fleet (Major Discount)

Why avoided:

• Multiple drivers (inconsistent care)
• High mileage typically
• Service quality unknown

Discount: 20-30%

Ex-Commercial/Taxi (Severe Discount)

Why tanks value:

• Extreme wear (200K+ km common)
• Poor maintenance
• Mechanical exhaustion

Discount: 40-50% (if disclosed)

In simple terms: Ownership is like rental history for apartments. Single tenant who cared = premium. Five tenants in 3 years = discount (unknown damage).

---

Regional Variations

Metro Cities (Delhi, Mumbai, Bangalore)

Preferences:

• Compact cars (parking constraints)
• Automatics (traffic congestion)
• Petrol (pollution norms)

Strong resale: Swift, i20, City automatic variants

Tier-2 Cities (Pune, Jaipur, Lucknow)

Preferences:

• SUVs (road conditions)
• Manual transmissions (cost-conscious)
• Diesel still valued (highway use)

Strong resale: Creta, Seltos, XUV700

Rural/Semi-Urban

Priorities:

• Ground clearance
• Service network reach
• Spare parts availability

Strong resale: Maruti SUVs (Brezza, Ertiga), Mahindra (Scorpio, Bolero)

Hills/Northeast

Specific requirements:

• Clutch life (hill driving)
• Engine strain resistance
• Service availability

Avoid: CVT/DCT (premature wear on hills)

---

Key Takeaways

✓ Brand hierarchy is real: Maruti 60-65% retention, Volkswagen only 35-45%

✓ White/Silver/Grey hold value: Bright colors lose 5-10%

✓ Petrol rising, diesel declining in small cars (SUVs still value diesel)

✓ Manual transmission strongest resale: CVT/DCT buyers hesitate (reliability fears)

✓ Single owner commands 10-15% premium: Three+ owners lose 10-20%

✓ Ex-commercial loses 40-50% value: Even after conversion to private registration

✓ Regional preferences vary: Metro wants automatics, tier-2 prefers diesel SUVs